Flying Under the Radar, Part 2

As noted by a friend, Jehovah’s Witnesses is a sect that seems to “fly under the radar.”  That is, they are, compared to other religions, left unexamined by media the average person would see or read:  no documentaries, Time magazine expose, movies or TVs about this sect.

erasebookWikipedia describes JWs as a “Christian denomination distinct from mainstream Christianity.”  While JWs use the Christian Bible (both old and new testaments – though, conveniently, their own version/translation), worship the god of that bible (monotheists); believe that Jesus of Nazarene was Christ the son of god who died for humankind’s sins and was then resurrected, they indeed are distinct from mainstream Christianity (and, in many ways I experienced, closer to a cult):

      • JWs do not celebrate Christmas, believing all birthdays are pagan celebrations (this applies to all birthdays of all people, even children), and do not celebrate Easter, arguing it too was once a pagan celebration.  (NB:  Historians would agree.)
      • JWs observe no holidays that other Christians seem to have no problems with:   Thanksgiving, Valentine’s Day, Halloween, New Year’s, Fourth of July, any presidents’ birthday (see above re birthdays), Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, etc.
      • JWs do not believe in hell or purgatory.  They do not believe people have a soul, rather, that people are souls.
      • JWs believe that only 144,000 out of all humanity (starting with Adam & Eve), will go to heaven.  Those 144,000 will be there to help Christ with his 1,000 year reign as the earth is restored to paradise (see my previous post for explanation of that restoration).
      • JWs observe the memorial of Christ’s death yearly.  It is a somber occasion, during which time a plate of unleavened crackers and a glass of wine are passed down the rows of the Kingdom Hall.  Only those who believe s/he is among the 144,000 (apparently they just “know” if they are), are to sip the wine and eat a cracker.  (As a child I would crane my head around to follow the plate and glass to see who might partake.  In JW upbringing, I saw only one person – my piano teacher – do so.)
      • Unlike mainstream Christians, JWs are required to attend a lot of bible study.  Let’s see … traditionally there was …
        1. The “Home Bible Study” for one hour one evening a week. (Our congregation had that meeting on Tuesday nights at 7:30-8:30 p.m.)  The congregations divide into groups of around 20 people, and each group is assigned a member’s home in which to meet.  There they would be led in Bible study by an elder or ministerial servant (think of that as elder-in-training).  That “study” consisted of people taking turns reading a paragraph from a JW publication, and then the elder/ministerial servant would read aloud the question (at the bottom of the page) for each paragraph and then select among the upraised hands for the answer to be read from the paragraph that was just read.  (By the way, JW publications are written at about an 8th grade level of reading and comprehension.)
        2. The Theocratic Ministry School:  Held weekly (in our congregation from every Thursday 7:30-9:30 p.m.)  There the audience was to learn how to “minister” door-to-door and lead individual bible studies.  (It was always very difficult to stay awake through the whole meetings, and I was always exhausted in school on Fridays.)
        3. Sunday meetings:  A two-hour affair starting (at our congregation) at 10 a.m.  (I’ve heard that later the length was reduced.)  The first hour was a public lecture by an elder or ministerial servant or a visiting elder on something related to JW doctrine, and the second hour was a “study’ based on an article in a recent Watchtower magazine (another JW publication).
          • The leader of the study hour was an elder or ministerial servant (only men).  After each paragraph was read by a chosen congregant, the leader would read aloud the question at the bottom of the paragraph.  Hands in the audience were ready, indicating a person’s ability to find and read the answer in the paragraph just read aloud.  (See parenthetical in #1 above.)
        4. paradiselost3JWs families would have (like Mormons), a Bible study night for the family.  It was based on a JW publication.  When I was a child it was the Paradise Lost book.  (Its gory illustrations about Armageddon gave me regular nightmares for years.)
        5. The most devout JW families started each morning reading a passage and discussion from yet another JW publication:  that year’s (if I recall the name correctly), Examining the Scriptures Daily.    There was a scripture and discussion for each day of that year.  (In addition to that book on our kitchen table one would always find a stack of Norwegian flatbread and a tides table book).
        6. JWs had yearly circuit (so many congregations made up a circuit) and district (so  many circuits made up a district) assemblies and every few years “international” assemblies.  (Those were always “big” events … especially for we girls who agonized over which dress to wear on each day so as to look our best as we hunted and modestly strutted for prospective mates.)
        7. JW children were not allowed to play and form friendships (outside of required school) with non-JW people.  Dating a non-JW is unthinkable and would, if it occurred, reveal the “weak” nature of that person’s faith.
        8. Like many religions, JWs are supposed to marry only other JWs.  Someone who married a non-JW (a Worldly person) was considered “weak” (that is, compared to a “strong” JW), and the rest of the congregation would do their best to help convert the Worldly spouse.  (My sister married two men who were both “Worldy;” my mother attended neither wedding.)
        9. While JWs pay are expected to pay all required taxes (“pay Cesar’s things to Cesar”), JWs will not serve on juries (only Jehovah can sit in judgment), they will not vote (they support only Jehovah’s kingdom), will not serve in the military (that puts one at risk of both serving a Worldly country and killing another person), or engage in political behavior (the only government they give their allegiance to is a theocracy).
        10. If a person baptized as a JW leaves the “Truth,” how s/he is treated depends on the reason for leaving:  (i) Disfellowshipping (where a tribunal of elders have confronted a JW for unchristian like conduct and the accused is unrepentant), results in all other JWs (including family) shunning the disfellowshipped person until that person realizes the errors of his/her ways, repents to the elders, and can be reinstated.  (ii) Disassociation (where a person simply formally severs her/his ties with the organization), results in the same thing: shunning (same as (i) above).  (iii) Inactive (where a person simply stops attending meetings etc.), results in regular attempts by JWs to bring the inactive person back into the Truth.
        11. JWs claim a Biblical reason for refusing blood transfusions and eating anything that might have blood in it.  Oddly (or maybe not!), the meat we could eat was always from a butcher or grocery store.  What was claimed to have blood in it changed over time.  At one point, our congregation elders announced JWs shouldn’t eat hotdogs or Tootsie Rolls, claiming both had blood in them.

Remaining Posts in this Series: 

Part 3:  How JWs revise/update their doctrines.

Part 4:  Why JWs come to your door, and what happens (on their end) when you politely take a tract (they’ll “be back”!).

Part 5:  How all this plays out in the daily life of a JW.


About sweatyknitter

Fiber art devotee, author, and amateur artisan bread baker.
This entry was posted in Miscellany and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

17 Responses to Flying Under the Radar, Part 2

  1. Emily says:

    That is interesting.


  2. Because, they believe, it is God’s mandate, something they have to do before Armaggedon. Also, they don’t see heaven as their goal; it is “life ever lasting” on the earth, restored to paradise during Christ’s millenium rule. During that 1,000 years, the JWs who survived Armaggedon, with Christ’s oversight, will return the earth to its original paradise (i.e., the Garden of Eden). God will resurrect (in reverse chronological order) those faithful AND those who didn’t have the opportunity to hear about Jehovah. Yes, I know it makes no sense. Little does, in JW doctrine. It is all taken on faith, and to question (literally – to ask questions!) is not only HIGHLY discouraged, but the questioning JW can be excommunicated for questioning “God’s word” as given to the JWs “through the Society.”


  3. Emily says:

    Here is what I do not understand about JWs: if there are only 144,000 people going to heaven in a world of several billion then why must they convert people? That makes less room for them and their families.


  4. In an upcoming post I reveal not just the JW doctrine about their door-to-door work but how it actually all works. Any ‘householder’ who seems interested or is perceived as being interested … Well, they will call on that householder again. Their goal: conversion.


  5. ethgran says:

    I do understand what you meant by regular scripture study – I just wanted folks to understand that our weekly FHE is designed to not only learn but bring families together in a meaningful way. I had a friend who had been a JW but never really asked what it was like because she said it was just awful. These blogs have been very informative and have helped me understand her attitude beside educating me in general. We haven’t altered the Bible yet believe that important truths have been left out over the many years since it was written then compiled. Looking forward to learning even more from your blogs – thanks!


  6. Given what you have described, absolutely NO resemblance – the Mormon FHE sounds like it could be fun/enjoyable. 🙂 What I meant was merely the regular home (family) bible study, though, certainly not a qualitative comparison. And you captured the JW way with your example: they will argue doctrine to the end – just don’t confuse their doctrine with actual scripture. 🙂

    Sent from my iPad



  7. ethgran says:

    I don’t think that the Mormon “Family Home Evening” resembles the bible study sessions you mentioned. With young children in the home we might tell Scripture stories with things like flannel boards and play acting. With older children more ‘discussion’ of the scriptures or various fun scripture themed games. Another perk was that we have refreshments (often prepared by one of the children with mom’s help) and always sang songs. Occasionally, we might go on a family outing. The point of having a “FHE” is to gather the family together as much as teaching.
    Years ago before my brain turned to mush, I taught the Old Testament to teenagers at an early morning session that we call Seminary (I often refer to it as Cemetery due to the number of sleeping participants – I didn’t did have any sleepers in my small group though, wink, wink). Several JW’s knocked on my door and presented me with a pamphlet which I looked at a saw a scripture that was familiar but was taken out of context which changed the meaning. When I pointed it out and quoted the scripture, they thanked me for my time and left. I love my religion and find it to be a joyous way of life. I can’t think there is much to be happy about being a JW.


  8. Glenda says:

    Supposed to be, yes. I like my vegan options as well as my pork!


  9. Yes, SDA did seem to be considered on the outskirts of Judeo-Christian religions … though I think JWs are even farther “out” … at least SDA aren’t restricted in terms of celebrating holidays. 🙂 Are SDAs supposed to be vegetarian?


  10. Glenda says:

    As I grow older, I find it hard to believe in any religion that imposes restrictions…well, that would be just about all of them. I was raised as a Seventh-Day Adventist, sometimes also considered a cult. As far as I could tell, the crucial SDA theology was the same as most other Judeo/Christian beliefs, but the biggest no-no of all is that it was founded by a woman, Ellen G. White. And they’ve had their run of kooky ideas, just like all of the others have. *sigh*


  11. jenyjenny says:

    I appreciate your posts on this, too. I’ve always been fascinated by religions of all kinds. As a child, I never would have imagined that someone would not be allowed to play with me because of their or my religion. I enjoyed having the JW sisters over to talk about religion when I lived in a different town, but I thought I was making it crystal clear that I didn’t plan to convert…


  12. I’m not sure as I never read the script. 😦



  13. jengolightly says:

    I think I saw that film! Was it about a teenage girl and her family thought the world was ending?


  14. I am glad you find it an interesting read. I once served as a consultant on an Australian movie. It wasn’t about JWs though; the producer wanted to ensure the portrayal of a character who happened to be a JW was correct.


  15. Thanks for commenting. Yes, school can be difficult for JW children. I wasn’t really bullied as much as silently mocked and alienated. Did you ever see Brian DiPalma’s “Carrie” movie? I related related to the main character – well, except I didn’t have the power to move things with my mind. 🙂 >


  16. empress27 says:

    This is extremely interesting. When I was younger my family and I would go to these meetings and abide by most of these rules, e.g. no Christmas or birthdays, attending meetings, door-to-door, etc. I’m not sure what it would have been like for me going out with non-JW guys as I was younger than 13 when we left. My father had left the congregation due to depression and we found the members extremely unhelpful. They also didn’t like the fact that my Father is a historian and enjoys playing wargames and tried to get him to stop. I recall one time they came to our house to chat to my Mother and quite blatantly ignored my Father in his own home. None of us went back to the congregation after that as it was despicable. Even now we are ignored. It doesn’t bother me at all. I find the religion fascinating but I no longer practice it. I don’t agree with many of the teachings they give. The main problems I had with it was the bullying at school. Thankfully I left school almost six years ago! Thanks for these posts, I’m finding them very interesting and insightful. It’s nice to see how other people have been affected by this religion.


  17. jengolightly says:

    This is fascinating!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s